Let me preface this article with the fact that I respect all people who are willing to work hard to achieve something great in their lives. But if you repeatedly lack good judgement, be prepared for the consequences. I respect hard work, but silliness is better left in the circus than in the gym. Always ask yourself, "Is what you're doing helping you, or hurting you?"  

I have worked and trained in many different facilities in my days, and I have seen all kinds of training from effective to silly to dangerous. The difference now is I know more than I used to know and I really care about the things I see. Instead of just making fun of people, having a good laugh and walking away, I now make fun of them, but try to give them some kind of helpful advice and feature them in a YouTube film as a parting gift. If I am fortunate enough to work with them closely, make them a part of my family and make a personal investment in their life, I do the very best I can to protect them and not allow them to do silly things. 



Below is a video I recently took at a friends facility, and I genuinely like the people, but I just thought some things were silly. It will offend a few, probably piss some people off, but I think the lesson learned by watching it will be more important than that fact that I might not be liked. 





The thing about this video is, it isn't an isolated incident, it is happening right now in thousands on gyms all over the place. In an effort to try to be the best, thousands of people are blindly following someone else's lead into despair. There are many great and terrible things about the fitness industry today. One pro is that fact that many people are willing to try new things to increase their ability. They are willing to work harder than ever to take their fitness to the next level. On the other hand, things have a tendency to get taken too far. Many people forget that they are training to be healthier, not training to save the Princess from the fire breathing dragon.


In 2007, I decided to add CrossFit to my list of fitness certifications. Ever since, CrossFit has become more and more popular. It is constantly evolving, growing, and attracting the likes of world renowned fitness celebrities such as Bob Harper, who was recently crowned his fourth Brown Eye Achievement Award from The Starfish Lounge six years running! Go Bob! Basically, Bob Harper exemplifies what it means to be a master of his craft, and now his craft includes CrossFit.  I mean, who needs Mark Rippetoe teaching flawless deadlift technique when you can have Bob Harper teaching a Turkish Get Up with less than 36 technical infringements?


If you want to be good at what you do, you have to understand what you are doing, why you are doing it, and how to do it safely and effectively. The first rule of training is "Do no harm." The coach and the athlete are both responsible for this. The athlete is sometimes stronger than he is smart, so it is the coaches responsibility to keep the athlete safe and progressing. In other words, the coach should take care of the athlete, but the athlete must always use common sense. 


Because of the juggernaut that CrossFit has become in the fitness community, millions of people are now getting most of their training information from them, and rightfully so, as they put out tons of incredible content from a variety of sources daily. At the risk of sounding cheesy by quoting Spiderman, with great power comes great responsibility. CrossFit has become one of the most powerful sources of fitness information out there. If you are programming exercises or competitions for people, you have the responsibility to keep those people safe. The head honchos in charge of CrossFit know very well that ten's of thousands of athletes are going to try to be the Worlds Fittest Man or Woman, and attempt to do their workouts regardless of their ability to perform them well. The CrossFit programmers are partially responsible for the fitness of the followers of the cult. But ultimately, the individual is responsible for themselves. 


When you have a novice athlete trying to perform an advanced training session or competition as fast as possible, it is like a football coach throwing a freshman high school football player into an NFL game and saying, "Tackle him!"  Sure he got in the game, but everyone saw something bad coming a mile away. In my opinion, the coach is to blame for failing to keep the athlete safe by exposing him to a situation that he was obviously not prepared for. 


In competition, attention to detail goes out the door, you simply rely on your training and instincts to produce the best possible results. Your strengths and weaknesses will be exposed for all to see on the field of battle. So I hope you prepared accordingly. For me, exercise is a practice. It is a means for me to practice doing something that will help me get better at sports and other great things life has to offer. But CrossFit ingeniously made exercise a sport in itself and the rest is history. Now people race through their training, many times without any respect for technique, make sweat angels on the floor and have entire closets full of t shirts from different gyms across the world. Its not all bad. 


The problem, Sir Lance A Lot, is that there is no dragon. Everybody wants to be a firebreather, but rarely does anybody want to pay the price of progression. For most people there is no need to crush yourself so bad in a workout session that you risk shoulder and knee injury to finish 12 seconds faster, no need to jump on a relatively short box 50 times as fast as possible or ever do butterfly pullups. I agree that everyone has the right to elite fitness and we all have free will, so your exercise selection and level of intensity is your choice. Years ago, CrossFit published an article entitled Fundamentals, Virtuosity and Mastery. It is a great piece and I recommend you read it. Basically it talks about the problems with trying to get too jiggy with your training and how the basics rule. But in recent years I see a lack of attention to detail and there is a strong desire to get crazier with training to either attract more attention or become more elite. I see a compromise from the original aim of the community.  I don't want to come across as an overly critical pussy here. I like hard work, but I like great results more. Unnecessary injuries are foolish. 


virtuosity.pdf
File Size: 68 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File


Most people simply need to move better. Then after they learn to move well, they need to learn to move well under load. Then they need to move well under load for reps. Then they need to move well under heavy load for high reps. But never put the cart before the horse. Dropping a dollar to pick up a dime never got anybody rich. Be sure to keep the goal the goal and always remember, do no harm. 


Everyone has the right to train and compete in any fashion that they want. But as a coach, I hate to see other coaches doing things that might harm the athletes. You can not stand around and watch bad shit happen, you must do the right thing and prevent it, fix it, and not turn a blind eye. Sometimes I see workouts that remind me of a train wreck suspense thriller gone bad. You don't wanna watch, but you can't turn away. Sometimes I wish people would throw in the towel instead of continuing on when nothing good can come out of it. But I guess that would be quitting, and the theme of the day is to never give up, so we have a catch 22.  If you're an athlete, please don't hurt yourself in the name of elite fitness, focus on getting stronger and doing things better. Paying someone money to have them kick you in the dick never made much sense to me. 


Every single thing you do in this world gets you closer to something. Practice according to the goal. Practice perfect reps if you want to get better at something, practice shitty reps if you want to get hurt, its that simple. Practice being the best coach, teacher, leader you can be.  I am as guilty as they come, I have made many mistakes and I am far from perfect. I have done many silly things in my day, but with experience comes wisdom. All athletes and coaches should be proud of their work. If a coach was to leave his class to be run by his mentor, what would the mentor think after watching the athletes perform? The coach should be proud to show off the athletes. If they are performing well or poorly, it is a representation of the coaching.  When you watch your athletes, do you cringe, are you ashamed, are you proud of what is happening? Would you use your daily training as an example of what to do and how to do it right? Do you exemplify leadership and integrity?   Or are you just trying to slay the dragon and pay the man behind the curtain at the end of the yellow brick road to do so?  I hope we have all learned something important here, coaches are responsible for guiding the path, but ultimately the individual is responsible to use common sense. Do things that set yourself up for success, not failure, yet don't sabotage your life by doing things the wrong or easy way. If the whole world was watching and you didn't know it, would you be proud of yourself? 
 


Comments

03/02/2012 2:15am

Just an awesome post. Xfit got many things right and many things wrong, I guess the lesson is to take away what is useful and discard the rest, not just with xfit but with everything. *bookmarked
Cheers mate

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 8:52am

Thanks, Finn

You're right, there are many more good things, and it is easy to point out what went wrong after the fact. As long as we keep learning in the process we keep growing.

Reply
Teddy
03/02/2012 2:31am

Watching that video is like a nightmare for me. I hurt my shoulders doing shitty snatches a year back, so the next time i'll start doing them, i'll definitely start with just a stick. How can those guys get through that workout without seriously hurting themselves?

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 8:53am

it wasn't pretty, it should have been stopped, but it is hard to say anything to a tough competitor in the heat of the moment

Reply
Alex
03/02/2012 5:03am

Great article and great piece of advice for all the people who think they should be the next "fittest man / woman of the world" without having quality years of strength training under their belt. You cant compare you with Rich Froning Jr. and Annie Thorisdottir.

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 8:55am

not enough people are willing to pay the price to do things right, they just want to be the champ now.

Reply
E Africa
03/02/2012 6:16am

great write up...even better video..outstanding "kick in the dick" reference, always fun to be reminded of my once foolish ways :).

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 8:59am

we were all foolish at one point, live and learn...

Reply
03/02/2012 7:29am

Great article Matt. I agree completely, I have gone through a load of crossfit certs in my time but in the past couple of years I have distanced myself from a lot of what is going on there now. With my athletes I always focus on mastering the basics - its not sexy but it works.

Unfortunately I have also done a tonne of stupid shit over the years in my own training but at least it has made me more aware of preventing others doing this. Incidentally since you have been doing my programming, I have made more gains in the past 3 months than in the past 2 years, thanks coach!

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 8:58am

i have been my own best and worst experiment for years. I realize that basics are best, but as the athlete develops and becomes more advanced, more challenge is necessary, but extreme challenge certainly is not beneficial if you can not perform the basics satisfactorily

Reply
03/02/2012 8:47am

Great post brother! Just keep doing what you're doing...

Reply
03/02/2012 8:57am

Awesome, well thought out and articulated piece that echoes much of what we feel as strength coaches regarding Crossfit and the state of training.

Matt, if you're ever in CT, you're always welcome at our facility.
www.ranfonetrainingsystems.com

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 9:00am

thanks, Scott, likewise...

Reply
Connor Flahive
03/02/2012 8:59am

Great post...but even better video.

Reply
Sven
03/02/2012 10:27am

Excellent post. Because everybody makes mistake who moves things - this is a good reminder to always listen to your body, get good coaching and keep it with the great B. Lee: "Keep what helps, cut what doesn't!".

Actually this is one of the reasons I don't like to go to gyms for strengthtraining anymore. It often gets my macho-guts going and I'm more open for mistakes due lack of concentration.
Cheers

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 9:04am

great points, Sven

Reply
05/31/2012 5:27am

This is great article -your content information's are very nice thanks for sharing.

Reply
Tamara E Cohen
03/02/2012 3:52pm

I wish more people had the balls to say, "You know, this workout just isn't worth it. I am not going to do it." And, I wish more affiliate owners had the balls to say, "I am not going to allow THAT to happen at MY gym." Bravo for a great post.

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 9:03am

Thanks, Tamara
it's funny how everybody wants to be a leader when its fun and easy, yet nobody wants the responsibility when shit could get ugly

Reply
Robert
03/02/2012 4:49pm

Is that video a joke? OMG! Never quit eh? That motto has been twisted in ways that result in videos like that one. Never quitting DOESN'T always mean the workout itself! For *&^% sake! It's about the long haul too. How about saying "It's not working today" OR "I am not ready for this drill or exercise" OR "I have crossed the line into crap........ time to stop."? Re evaluate and build that foundation. Keep at it consistently. THAT'S NOT QUITTING TOO! Sheesh.

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 9:04am

right on, Robert

Reply
Pearse
03/02/2012 9:06pm

What happened to the video? Not showing up for me.

Reply
Chris
03/03/2012 10:18am

Ditto

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 9:05am

I took the video down because it was the right thing to do...

Reply
Mike
03/02/2012 9:24pm

Yeah, no video. GREAT article though.

Reply
John
03/03/2012 11:12am

I agree with this, Matt - very well written.

The CrossFit Games are set to find the fittest individuals on the planet, and while I don't agree that this would be an effective workout to train an athlete, it is a typical way for CrossFit to test fitness. It involves strength, skill, power, work capacity, etc..

The sad fact is that many CrossFitters have no business attempting a 165# snatch, let alone at a heart rate of 170 - it just is not safe. That alone should take them out of consideration for this contest. It is the responsibility of the coaches running these facilities to shut these athletes down before something bad happens when a workout like this pops up. Yes - do the workout if that's what you're in to, but scale it according to your ability level. That is what CrossFit wants you to do. Too many people think they're going to be the next Rich Froning Jr. and go to the CrossFit Games.

If a coach was allowing that to go on (the video that you just took down) at my gym, he would be fired on the spot. It's sad to see that level of carelessness going on in this profession on such a widespread basis.

Matt - why did that video come down? It was hard to watch but the commentary was hilarious.

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 9:10am

I took the video down because it was the right thing to do. People were getting hurt, and I think I made my point. I suggest there be a rule that if you have 3 consecutive missed attempts (which can get bad for many reasons, but mostly for injury prevention) your set should be terminated. There is no reason, in my opinion, to try the 12th, 13th, 14th, ... failed rep when they are no where near acceptable or safe and even are counterproductive. A couch who watches that happen actually is responsible for the regression of the athlete.

Reply
Chris Woods
03/03/2012 3:10pm

I agree with 100% of this post. I keep hearing people bitch that the organizers of the Open in some way failed in their obligation to the safety of participants in the programming of this workout. I would guess that almost every participant registered for this competition is perfectly capable of completing at least one rep SAFELY at the opening weight for their division, and thereby getting a qualifying score. CrossFit HQ's primary purpose in these events is to find the best athletes to pass on to the next level; breadth of participation is secondary. This workout was actually very well programmed for both purposes. It starts out light enough that almost anyone can do the first round or at least part of it, and it ends heavy enough to truly separate the elite athletes from the rest. It's the responsibility of the athlete or coach to know what level of participation they are capable of. For my part, I can say that there were several people in our gym who completed the first or second weight and were unable to continue. Most people new where that point would be going in, and some were allowed to make one or two attempts at a weight which was near their max and then acquiesce. That's our responsibility as coaches, to know where that line is, not the responsibility of an event organizer. By the same logic, if an athlete with achilles tendonitis enters a marathon and blows out their achilles during the race, it's not the fault of the event organizers. The parameters of the event were public knowledge, it's the responsibility of the participant to know whether or not it's within their range of ability. Despite what some detractors might say, I have never seen the workout that I consider inherently unsafe. A workout is only unsafe if it is not within the capacity of the athlete to perform it safely.

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 9:11am

well said

Reply
03/04/2012 2:34am

Great post. I agree, there are a lot negligence going around, but like it or not CrossFit is going to be THE medium through which the majority of regular people discover functional fitness. We can either sit on the sidelines and scold while patting ourselves on the back, or lead the front from within.

Reply
Matt Wichlinski
03/06/2012 9:12am

exactly, lets get back to work

Reply
Is gg pukie
03/04/2012 7:34am

Cf only invented fitness comedy

Reply
03/10/2012 4:03pm

Hey man, great post. This whole workout drove me nuts, and you hit on some of the key points that got to me as well.

The elite crossfitters, those bound for Regionals and Games, can and largely (a few well-known XFitters went down with shoulder injuries from this one) did survive this workout. It wasn't a training session, it was competition. Injuries happen in competition and this was obviously thrown together (word choice intentional) to divide the field.

At face value it's easy to say "well, people should work within their limits" and "it'll really show who the elites are", which is what the official stance is.

However, everyone, including HQ, knows damn well that 98% of the 50,000 people trying this workout are not qualified to be doing it. They're not going to place highly enough to move on to the next level even if they have their best day. They're exposing themselves to huge injury potential. At best they're messing up what little snatch motor pattern they do have by practicing shitty technique under fatigue.

So there's no gain. There's no upside. Like the high school player in the NFL game you mentioned, they're being thrown into a bad situation that isn't going to really give them any benefit even if they do somehow succeed.

When the potential for harm is this big and the benefit is so low, that's a responsibility problem on the programmer's part. There are other ways to separate the field without the downsides.

Way to man up and post, dude.

Isaac

Reply
03/11/2012 9:16am

Damn fine post Matt, well written and true.

The only people that will get mad at this are the ones that are ashamed.


Reply
Joe P.
03/12/2012 8:37pm

First of all, I have followed your blog and youtube vids for a few years running, and I truly believe that you are among the elite trainers/strength athletes on the east coast. I've been involved in high school/college football,wrestling, amateur boxing, and crossfit just to name a few of the athletic endeavors I've participated in. I've been trained by many different coaches, and I'm very impressed with your expertise. I've learned a great deal just from exposure to your online content. Secondly, I think that this is a very important discussion to have in the fitness industry at this point with the vast proliferation of crossfit. A lot of the lifts involved in the crossfit workouts require a GREAT DEAL of technical skill, much more than many crossfiters can appreciate. The potential for SEVERE, and LIFE CHANGING, injury is very high with olympic lifts. It is the responsibility of coaches to emphasize this during instruction, and the responsibility of athletes to respect these lifts during training.

Reply
05/09/2012 1:17am

Wow what a man this is your daily practices. Are you know games the related information's are given there.

Reply
Sean
05/22/2012 6:20pm

Ditto

Reply



Leave a Reply


 

 

 

 

 

 

Home | Blog | Forum | Articles | Products | Testimonials | Membership | Contact Us